
Daniel Case · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons
Updated
Judges on New York's Court of Appeals questioned whether trial judges may require defendants to waive appeal rights as a condition of a sentence, Courthouse News Service reported. The seven-judge panel heard arguments on Thursday in the case of Glaston Gaines, who in 2023 was offered a sentence of 10 to 13 years for a robbery charge, instead of up to 25 years, if he pleaded guilty and waived his right to appeal. He was sentenced to 12 years. His lawyer, Legal Aid attorney Sarod Nori, argued the waiver was a threat to the legitimacy of the criminal justice system because it amounted to coercion by an impartial judge, and that a sentence is not a bargaining chip. The state's attorney, April Orlowski, said a defendant asking to speak should probably be allowed to do so. Judge Caitlin Halligan said such waivers could create an appearance of bias by insulating a judge's decision from review, asking how the system could survive if the public thought judges had skin in the game. Judge Michael Garcia suggested such issues could be handled case by case in the appellate division. The court did not issue a ruling after the hearing. Courthouse News Service noted that New York's approach rests largely on a 1989 ruling in People v. Seaberg, which allowed defendants to waive appeal rights for a more favorable sentence, and that earlier this year a mid-level appellate court in People v. Turner required a trial court to state its rationale on the record.
Show New York on the map